30 Best Things to Resell For a Profit at a Garage Sale

Updated on: by Amy Kennedy
art works on display in a garage sale

Garage sales are not just about decluttering; they offer the chance to rediscover value in forgotten items.

Need Easy Extra $350+/Month For Free?

  • SwagBucks: Watch videos, take surveys, shop and more to earn real money. Earn up to $35 per survey! No hidden fees and completely free. Join Swagbucks Now to Get $5 Free
  • InboxDollars: Has so far paid its members over $40 Million. Watch videos, take surveys, shop and more. Join InboxDollars Now and Get Free $5
  • SurveyJunkie: Make $5-$25 in your spare time from home to take online surveys, participating in a Focus Groups and trying new products. Join SurveyJunkie Now
  • Branded Surveys: Complete online surveys. Collect points. Redeem your points for cash & gift cards. No hidden fees and completely free! Has so far paid its members over $18 Million. Join Branded Surveys Now

With the right knowledge and presentation, everyday objects can transform into sought-after treasures, bringing in unexpected profits.

Recognizing what’s in demand and understanding the market can make your next garage sale not just a cleaning exercise, but also a lucrative venture.

1. Vintage Clothing

Timeless Appeal

Vintage clothing captures a bygone era, reflecting styles and trends of the past. Especially pieces from the ’60s, ’70s, and ’80s, resonate with fashion enthusiasts, offering a nostalgic journey back in time.

The unique designs and fabrics are often hard to find in contemporary fashion, making them valuable.

Designer Finds

Authentic vintage designer items can be gold mines. Whether it’s a handbag, shoes, or a dress, if they’re in good condition, they can be resold at significantly higher prices.

Designer labels carry a legacy of quality and style, appealing to collectors and fashion aficionados alike.

2. Board Games

Nostalgic Value

Board games, especially classics like Monopoly or Clue, hold significant nostalgic value. For many, they are reminiscent of childhood memories, family gatherings, and playful afternoons.

A complete set, with all pieces intact, can be a treasure for collectors and families seeking to recreate those memories.

Rare Editions

Limited-edition board games or versions that have been discontinued increase in value over time. For board game enthusiasts, finding a rare edition can be like finding a missing puzzle piece for their collection.

Some editions might have unique designs or components that are no longer available, making them particularly valuable.

3. First Edition Books

Collector’s Dream

For many bibliophiles, owning a first edition of a classic novel or a favorite author’s work is a dream. These editions often carry nuances that might have been edited out in later prints.

Their rarity and historical significance can make them highly sought after.

Signatures Boost Value

Imagine finding a signed first edition by a renowned author like J.K. Rowling or Stephen King. A signature not only authenticates the book but also provides a personal touch, connecting the reader directly to the author.

Such books can fetch impressive prices, especially among collectors.

4. Vinyl Records

Auditory Nostalgia

With the resurgence of vinyl records in modern culture, old collections are again in demand. Albums from iconic artists, particularly in excellent condition, are hot commodities.

Need Easy Extra Cash?

Pinecone Research, a leading name in online survey panel honesty, absolutely guarantees $3 cash for every survey you complete!
Take advantage of their time limited New Membership drive and register NOW. Join today: 100% free!

Join Pinecone Research Now

These records offer an analog warmth and tactile experience that digital formats can’t match.

Vintage Album Art

Beyond the music, the album art—especially from iconic releases—holds immense value. Collectors often seek vintage album covers, not just for the music inside, but for the aesthetic appeal and the story each cover tells.

5. Antique Furniture

Craftsmanship and History

The allure of antique furniture lies in its unique craftsmanship and the history embedded in each piece. Well-preserved items that highlight period-specific designs or bear marks of a renowned craftsman can fetch impressive prices.

Restoration Potential

While some buyers seek pristine pieces, others look for items they can restore. Antique furniture that might appear worn or damaged can be valuable for restoration enthusiasts looking for their next project.

6. Rare Collectibles

Limited-edition Items

Collectibles, such as commemorative coins, limited-edition stamps, or unique figurines, always have a market. Their value often appreciates over time, especially if they’re associated with significant events or personalities.

Historical Memorabilia

Items that capture a slice of history, be it from world events, cinema, or music, can attract collectors. Such items offer more than just material value; they offer a tangible connection to the past.

7. Vintage Electronics

Retro Vibes

Classic gadgets like Walkmans, early gaming consoles, or rotary phones are no longer just devices—they’re memories. Collectors and tech enthusiasts alike often seek these items for their nostalgic value and historical significance.

Tech Evolution Evidence

Owning a piece of technology that marks a significant point in the evolution of devices can be thrilling for tech aficionados. These items serve as reminders of how far technology has come.

8. Jewelry

Precious Materials

Gold, silver, and gemstones have an enduring appeal. Even as fashion trends change, the intrinsic value of these materials remains. Jewelry can be particularly profitable if it has a unique design or historical significance.

Unique Craftsmanship

Handcrafted or custom-designed pieces stand out in the vast world of jewelry. Their uniqueness, combined with the story behind their creation, can significantly increase their resale value.

9. Sports Memorabilia

Fanatic Attraction

Sports enthusiasts are often on the lookout for jerseys, equipment, or other items associated with their favorite athletes or teams. An autographed item or something used in a significant game can be a gold mine.

Historical Games

Collectibles from landmark games or iconic moments in sports history can be of immense value. They hold not just the thrill of the sport, but a piece of history that fans cherish.

10. Musical Instruments

Timeless Sound

Musical instruments, whether modern or vintage, always have a market. Instruments like guitars, violins, or pianos never go out of style. While musical tastes may evolve, the allure of creating music remains timeless.

Vintage Instruments

Brands with a storied history or older instruments known for their distinct sound can attract collectors and musicians alike. Instruments that are no longer in production can especially fetch higher prices due to their rarity.

11. Artwork

Aesthetic Value

From renowned artists to local talents, artwork can be a significant draw. Even prints or lesser-known pieces can attract art enthusiasts or those looking to beautify their spaces.

Historical Significance

Pieces that represent a specific era, art movement, or cultural moment have more than aesthetic appeal; they offer a connection to a different time and place. Artwork that tells a story or captures a moment in history can be particularly valuable.

12. Cameras and Lenses

Photography Enthusiasts

Old-school film cameras, especially from reputable brands, are becoming increasingly popular among photography enthusiasts. There’s a charm to shooting on film that digital cameras can’t replicate.

Technical Specifications

Vintage lenses, particularly those with unique features or from prominent brands, can fetch a high resale value. Some lenses are sought after for their specific optical characteristics, creating a demand among professional photographers and hobbyists alike.

13. Handmade Crafts

Unique Appeal

Handmade items, be it quilts, pottery, or other crafts, hold a charm that mass-produced items can’t match. They resonate with those looking for unique, one-of-a-kind pieces.

Craftsmanship Value

The time, effort, and skill that goes into creating handmade crafts often reflect in their resale value. Buyers appreciate the craftsmanship and the story behind each item.

14. Toys and Action Figures

Childhood Memories

For many, toys and action figures are a trip down memory lane. Vintage toys, especially those in mint condition or in their original packaging, can be highly sought after by collectors.

Limited Editions and Rare Finds

Special edition toys or those that were produced in limited quantities often carry higher resale values. They can be the crown jewels in a collector’s trove.

15. Antique Tools

Durability and Design

Older tools were often made with an emphasis on durability and craftsmanship. This quality, coupled with unique designs, makes them attractive to both tool users and collectors.

Historical Relevance

Tools that provide insight into bygone craftsmanship techniques or that were used in significant historical events can hold immense value.

16. Watches and Clocks

Timeless Elegance

Branded watches, especially vintage ones, are always in demand. A well-maintained watch not only tells time but also speaks of its owner’s style and sophistication.

Mechanical Marvels

Older mechanical watches and clocks, with their intricate movements, are particularly attractive to collectors. Their craftsmanship is a testament to the expertise of watchmakers of the past.

17. Rare Magazines and Newspapers

Snapshot of History

Old magazines and newspapers provide a direct glimpse into the past, capturing moments of historical significance or cultural shifts.

Collectible Covers

Magazines with iconic covers, be it featuring celebrities or marking significant events, can be valuable. Collectors often seek out such issues to complete their collections.

18. Postcards

Windows to Different Worlds

Historic or uniquely illustrated postcards are miniature snapshots of different places and eras. Collectors appreciate them for their artistry and the stories they tell.

Earn Everything… nearly!

Join Opinion Outpost, one of the few faithful and honest survey panels and earn cash and gift cards for your opinion. Stack your points and redeem them: Simple! No hidden fees and completely free!

Join Opinion Outpost Now

Messages from the Past

Sometimes, it’s the handwritten notes on these postcards that hold more value than the postcard itself. They offer a personal glimpse into someone’s life or journey.

19. Vintage Kitchenware

Nostalgic Designs

Classic designs, especially from the ’50s and ’60s, have a charm that’s perennially appealing. Think of colorful Pyrex bowls or enamel cookware. These pieces evoke memories of family dinners and festive gatherings, making them desirable to collectors.

Branded Pieces

Certain brands, like Le Creuset or Fire-King, have developed a cult following. Items from such brands, especially if in good condition, can fetch impressive prices.

20. Sports Equipment

Retro Sports Gear

Old-school sports gear, like wooden tennis rackets or leather football helmets, can be valuable, especially to collectors. They offer a snapshot of how sports have evolved over the decades.

Popular Brand Equipment

Top brands in sports equipment, such as Wilson or Spalding, always have a market. Even older items can be attractive if they’re in usable condition or have a unique aesthetic.

21. Vintage Eyewear

Retro Styles

Old-school eyeglass frames, especially from the mid-century, are making a comeback. Brands like Ray-Ban or Gucci, known for their timeless designs, can be particularly valuable.

Iconic Sunglasses

Think of the aviators from the ’70s or cat-eye glasses from the ’50s. These iconic styles, especially if in pristine condition, are always in demand.

22. Old Letters and Manuscripts

Historical Insights

Handwritten letters from the past offer direct insight into historical events and personal experiences. Letters that shed light on significant events or periods can be of high value.

Literary Manuscripts

Finding an original manuscript or an early draft from a known author can be a jackpot. Such pieces provide a unique perspective on the author’s thought process and the evolution of their work.

23. Vintage Advertising Signs

Industrial Art

Old advertising signs, especially those made of metal or porcelain, are often sought after by collectors. They offer a blend of art and commercialism, capturing the essence of different eras.

Iconic Brands

Advertisements from globally recognized brands like Coca-Cola or Ford, especially those that are no longer in circulation, can fetch high prices.

24. Military Memorabilia

Historical Significance

Items from World Wars, like medals, uniforms, or badges, are always in demand among history buffs. They capture the essence of significant events and the sacrifices made during those times.

Unique Stories

Personal belongings of soldiers, like diaries or letters, offer a personal window into the lives of those who served. These can be particularly valuable to collectors and historians alike.

25. Vintage Radios

Classic Designs

The design and craftsmanship of old radios, especially those from the Art Deco period, make them desirable. They serve as a reminder of a time when radios were the primary source of entertainment and news.

Operational Value

Radios that are still functional can be of higher value. Enthusiasts often seek them out for their authentic sound quality and nostalgic appeal.

26. Maps and Atlases

Geographical Journeys

Old maps and atlases provide a perspective on how our understanding of the world has evolved. They offer a snapshot of geographical knowledge of their time.

Artistic Appeal

Historical maps, especially hand-drawn ones with intricate details, are also appreciated for their artistic value. They can be a collector’s delight and an explorer’s treasure.

27. Vintage Magazines

Cultural Snapshots

Old magazines, whether they are fashion-focused like Vogue or news-centric like Time, capture the zeitgeist of their era. They offer insights into the fashion, culture, and major events of their time.

Iconic Covers

Magazines featuring significant personalities or events on their covers, especially if in good condition, can be highly sought after by collectors.

28. Handmade Rugs

Traditional Craftsmanship

Handmade rugs, especially those from regions known for their rug-making traditions like Persia or Turkey, are always in demand. Their intricate designs and quality craftsmanship make them timeless pieces.

Historical Significance

Certain rugs carry historical or cultural stories woven into their designs. Recognizing and understanding these narratives can significantly increase their value.

29. Costume Jewelry

Stylish Designs

While they may not have the intrinsic value of fine jewelry, costume pieces, especially vintage ones, are sought after for their designs. Brands like Monet or Trifari have developed a following over the years.

Nostalgic Value

Jewelry from specific eras, like the Art Deco or Victorian period, can be particularly valuable. They resonate with both collectors and fashion enthusiasts.

30. Old Coins and Currency

Monetary History

Old coins and paper money provide a tangible connection to the economic history of nations. Rare coins or currency notes, especially those with misprints, can be of high value.

Aesthetic Appeal

Beyond their monetary value, coins and notes from the past, especially those with intricate designs or artwork, are also appreciated for their beauty. Collectors often seek them out for their aesthetic and historical value.


Every item in our homes holds a potential story and value, often beyond what meets the eye. As the saying goes, “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure.”

With a discerning eye and a bit of research, you can transform forgotten items into coveted treasures.

So, before discarding anything, take a moment to assess its potential worth—it might just be the hidden gem someone has been searching for.

Related Posts:

Earn Everything… nearly!

Join Ipsos iSay, one of the few Faithful and Honest survey panels and earn prizes, gift cards and donations. Stack your points and redeem them: Simple! No hidden fees and completely free!

Join Ipsos Now


Click here to post a comment...
Post comment